38. Opposition (睽)

Line 3

If this line changes it transforms into 14. Possession in Great Measure (大有)

Modern reading

Line 3 faces severe impediments and misdirected suspicion while caught between opposing forces, yet perseverance tends to foster a favorable outcome. Though the journey begins with heavy resistance, ultimate alignment with the upper line brings lasting vindication.

Ask your AI about this page

Your question (optional)

Links prefill your prompt without sending it — you stay in control. If a link fails, copy the prompt below.

ChatGPT Claude Grok Gemini Perplexity DeepSeek Qwen

Prompt preview

I Ching / BaZi reading request (from eastalmanac.com).
Page: Hexagram 38 睽 — Line 3.
Interpret through classical principles in two layers: 1) Structural Evidence: identify key line dynamics, changing line pivot, or element balance. 2) Actionable Verdict: direct answer to the inquiry in plain language, followed by 2–3 concrete next steps (action-verb first) and mindful cautions. Grounded wisdom for self-reflection. Source page:
https://eastalmanac.com/yijing/38/3

I Ching casting

Six in the third place is an improper yin line hemmed in between strong yang lines, depicted traditionally as a stalled cart whose driver suffers unfair humiliation.

Nevertheless, its true correspondence with Nine at the top and the transformed hexagram Dayou (Hexagram 14), embodying the vitality of renewal at extremity, point toward eventual release, fulfilling the classical formula of an unfortunate start followed by a triumphant finish.

Enduring initial misunderstanding with steady patience turns temporary grievance into genuine resolution.

Career

Projects may encounter sudden obstacles, stalled momentum, or unwarranted blame arising from conflicting agendas above and below your position.

Classical counsel warns against impulsive retaliation, noting that steadfast execution will eventually attract the high-level backing needed to clear your name. Weathering early friction patiently allows your true competence to shine through.

Love & relationships

A partnership may face intense outside criticism or heavy misunderstandings that leave both individuals feeling wounded and misunderstood. If core mutual loyalty remains unbroken beneath the surface, the truth will gradually disperse external gossip and restore harmony.

Working through early hardships together leaves the relationship far more resilient than before.

Wealth

Financial transactions or contractual settlements may encounter frustrating delays, bureaucratic penalties, or conflicting claims.

Pouring additional resources into a jammed process only increases exposure, whereas carefully preserving records allows difficulties to resolve over time. Holding steady through temporary financial roadblocks helps rightful returns eventually arrive.

References

Original text

Line statement

3. In the third line, divided, we see one whose carriage is dragged back, while the oxen in it are pushed back, and he is himself subjected to the shaving of his head and the cutting off of his nose. There is no good beginning, but there will be a good end.

Small Image

‘We see his carriage dragged back:’—this is indicated by the inappropriateness of the position (of the line). ‘There is no (good) beginning, but there will be a (good) end:’—this arises from his meeting with the strong (subject of the topmost line).

Classical commentary

Zhouyi BenyiLine statement

Yè is pronounced yǐ-zhì-fǎn. Chè is pronounced chāng-shì-fǎn. Yì is pronounced yú-qì-fǎn.

Six in the Third Place and Nine at the Top are proper partners, but the Third resides between two yang lines: pulled back by the Second from behind and obstructed by the Fourth in front.

Furthermore, in a time of Opposition, Nine at the Top is deeply suspicious and fierce, so there is also the wound of having the hair shaved and the nose cut off. Yet evil cannot overcome righteousness, and in the end they must unite; hence the image and divination are such.

Yichuan YizhuanLine statement

Yin and yielding are normally insufficient to stand alone, let alone during a time of Opposition and estrangement! Three sits between two firm lines, finding no secure footing; that it suffers encroachment and humiliation is obvious.

Three takes its proper partner above, wishing to advance and unite its will with the Top, but the Fourth blocks it in front, and the Second drags it from behind.

The wagon and the ox are the instruments of travel; 'the wagon is dragged back' means pulled from behind; 'its ox is halted' means obstructed in front.

That which is behind merely drags it back, but that which is in front must be forcefully resisted by the one advancing; hence the heavier injury comes from above, being harmed by the Fourth: 'Its man is subjected to forehead-branding and nose-cutting.'

Tiān means shaving the head or branding the brow; yì means lopping off the nose.

Three follows its proper partner while the Fourth blocks and halts it; although Three is yin and yielding, it occupies a firm seat and its will is set on moving forward, so it forcefully pushes ahead against resistance and is thus injured.

Suffering branding and furthermore nose-cutting speaks of severe injury. Three does not harmonize with Two and Four; in a time of Opposition, there is naturally no reason to unite with them, which happens to conform to the Dao of occupying firmness and keeping correctness.

Regarding its proper partner, when Opposition reaches its peak, there is the principle of ultimate union. Having no beginning means being initially distressed by the two yangs; having an end means ultimately attaining union.

Chè is composed of 'to control' and 'hand', carrying the meaning of holding back and stopping. The Xiang Commentary says: 'Seeing the wagon dragged back' is because the position is not appropriate. 'No beginning, but an end' is because it meets with the firm.

Six occupying the Third Place is not correct; when not correct, one is ill at ease. Moreover, being placed between two yangs, the reason it suffers such hardship and distress is because the position is not appropriate.

'No beginning, but an end' means that in the end it is bound to meet and unite with Nine at the Top, which is meeting with the firm.

When union is formed through impropriety, it has never lasted long without estrangement; but when union is formed through the correct Dao, there is naturally no principle of endless opposition.

Therefore, the worthy follow principle and walk in peace, while the wise perceive subtle signs and stand firm.

Zhouyi ZhuLine statement

Whenever things are near yet do not get along, misfortune follows.

Dwelling in a time of Opposition, treading in a position not its own, being a yin line occupying a yang place and a yielding line riding over a firm one: its will is directed toward the top, yet it is not in harmony with the Fourth, while the Second responds to the Fifth, thus being close neighbors that do not hold together; hence 'he sees the wagon dragged back'.

'The wagon dragged back' means that because it treads in an improper position, it loses that which carries it. 'Its ox halted' means that where obstruction exists, it cannot advance.

'Its man is subjected to forehead-branding and nose-cutting': the Fourth takes from above, the Second takes from below, yet its resonance lies with Nine at the Top, holding its will without wavering. Though initially troubled, in the end it obtains firm assistance.

Zhouyi ZhengyiLine statement

'Six in the Third Place: he sees the wagon dragged back, its ox halted...' down to 'no beginning, but an end.'

The Correct Meaning states: 'He sees the wagon dragged back, its ox halted': dwelling in a time of Opposition, treading in an improper position, with yin dwelling in a yang seat and yielding riding on firmness, its will is set on Nine at the Top and does not unite with the Fourth.

The Second naturally resonates with the Fifth, and is also at odds with oneself. Wishing to carry, its wagon is dragged back, losing what it carries. Wishing to advance, its ox is held back, obstructed by obstacles so that it cannot move forward.

Hence it is said: 'He sees the wagon dragged back, its ox halted.' 'Its man is subjected to forehead-branding and nose-cutting; no beginning, but an end': branding the brow is tiān, cutting off the nose is yì.

Since it resides between Two and Four and agrees with neither, as for this person, the Fourth inflicts punishment from above by branding his brow, and the Second inflicts punishment from below by cutting off his nose; hence it is said, 'Its man is subjected to forehead-branding and nose-cutting.'

'Yet its resonance lies with Nine at the Top, holding its will without turning back; though initially troubled, in the end it gains firm assistance', hence it is said, 'No beginning, but an end.'

Zhouyi ZhengyiSmall Image

'The Xiang Commentary says...' down to 'having an end is meeting with the firm.'

The Correct Meaning states: 'The position is not appropriate': because the position is not appropriate, the wagon is dragged back. 'Meeting with the firm': because it meets the firmness of Nine at the Top, it has an end.

Yicuo JinLine statement

Six in the Third Place, third line, Lower-Lower: The cauldron boils amidst storm and waves; a lone boat crosses the river. Clumsiness hides within cleverness; human affairs drift and slip away.